With the continued expansion of Hong Kong as one of the world’s major auction hubs and the growing sophistication of the city’s collectors, according to Christie’s Head of 20th and 21st Century Art in the Asia-Pacific region, Cristian Albu, there is a conscious effort to bring popular art from not just the East but also the West to the city’s auction floors. Christie’s is reflecting this trend in their 20th/21st Century Evening Sale happening on 28 March.
Led by a Jean-Michel Basquiat painting, the sale is full of other works by other prominent and well-established artists with proven records of fetching high prices at auction. These include Zao Wou-Ki, René Magritte, Yayoi Kusama, and Pierre-Auguste Renoir, who all represent an array of styles and periods of art. There are also emerging artists represented in the sale, one of whom is Zhang Enli, whose painting Intimacy is the sixth most highly estimated lot of the sale.
Belgian artist René Magritte's Rêverie de Monsieur James is the second most highly estimated lot of the sale with an estimate between HK$42-55 million (around US$5.4-7.0 million). The Basquiat that leads the sale is a stunning two-meter-tall work that displays his vivid artistry; you can read more about it here.
The sale, consisting of 43 lots, also coincides with Art Basel, a first for Christie’s Hong Kong. The inclusion of a Renoir also overlaps with an exhibition of the French artist's work at the Hong Kong Museum of Art, further drumming up interest in the Impressionist's work, as his paintings are not often brought to Asian auction floors.
Lot 10 | René Magritte (1898-1967) | Rêverie de Monsieur James, Oil on canvas
Painted in 1943
54.3 x 73.7 cm
Provenance:
- Lou Cosyn, Brussels, acquired from the artist
- Private collection; Sotheby Parke Bernet London, 31 March 1982, lot 108
- Davlyn Gallery, New York, acquired at the above sale
- Sandra Moss, California, acquired from the above, circa 1984; Sotheby’s New York, 28 October 2020, lot 104
- Acquired at the above sale by the present owner
Estimate: HK$42,000,000-55,000,000 (around US$5.4-7.0 million)
René Magritte once stated, “I have found a new potential inherent in things, their ability to become gradually something else, and an object merging into an object other than itself… This seems to me to be something quite different from a composite object, since there is no break between the two substances and no limit.” This core principle seems to be the driving force behind Rêverie de Monsieur James, where seven hands extend out of a rose bush, the fingers entwined with the roses themselves.
Magritte named the work after Edward James, an English aristocrat and poet who was a patron of Surrealism. Magritte met James in 1936 in Paris, while the latter was engaged in renovating famous British properties such as Monkton House in the image of Surrealism with the aid of such individuals as Salvador Dalí. Interested in Magritte’s work, James invited him to England, where the former would produce three works for James to display at his London townhouse.
James was so pleased with Magritte's work that before Magritte returned to Belgium, James would commission a fourth work from him, and the work that would emerge from this, Le principe du plaisir, would be the precursor to Rêverie de Monsieur James. When Magritte worked on paintings for James, it was always a collaborative process, with this lot being no different, as Magritte credits James for the idea of the flowers and the female hands that dominate this painting.
René Magritte | Le Principe du plaisir (1937), Oil on canvas | Sold for US$26.8 million by Sotheby's New York, November 2018
Regarding the meaning of the work, Magritte used these different objects to reveal inner truths and to create dynamic meanings that came together like poetry between these different parts. In this painting, the core theme between the various parts seems to be a disconnect. The hands sprout from the bushes but hold the flowers. The different components pull against each other in strange and surreal ways.
The style of this work was further informed by the events of the times. The German occupation of Belgium and its horrors saw Magritte adopt impressionist brush techniques, applying them to more whimsical and beautiful works as a sort of distraction from the reality of war, almost a form of artistic escapism.
Lot 18 | Zao Wou-Ki (1920-2013) | 28.8.67, Oil on canvas
Painted in 1967
89 x 116 cm
Provenance:
- Galerie de France, Paris
- Private collection, Paris (acquired from the above in 1972)
- Ivoire Nantes, 23 March 2013, lot 40
- De Sarthe, Hong Kong
- Private collection, Asia (acquired from the above)
- Acquired from the above by the present owner
Estimate: HK$40,000,000-60,000,000 (around US$5.1-7.7 million)
The era between 1959 and 1972 is referred to as Zao Wou-Ki’s “Hurricane Period.” The over-decade-long period is considered the apex of Zao Wou-Ki’s creativity and artistic output. This painting on sale with Christie’s was one of 100 large panel-sized works produced during this whirlwind of artistic output.
This golden age of Zao’s work was not heavily influenced by Chinese culture, which appeared post-1972 following the loss of his wife and travels through China. When he arrived in France in 1948, he wanted to distance himself from the art of his birthplace for various reasons. On the surface level, he did not want to become a token Chinese painter forced into that bubble. He also felt that Chinese ink paintings were too restraining and traditional; instead, his work took on a more Western influence.
Zao Wou-Ki | 12.05.60 (1960), Oil on canvas | Sold for HK$4.9 million (around US$6.3 million) by China Guardian Hong, October 2020
This is not to say he rejected all aspects of Chinese art. Zao’s designs were almost always influenced by oracle bone script from ancient China combined with densely saturated color and abstract styles, something he picked up in America in 1957. Another aspect of Zaoi’s work that may have been picked up from Chinese art is the usage of calligraphy-esque lines in the center of the painting. In other works, such as 12.05.60 sold by China Guardian Hong Kong in 2020, this is described as an abstract calligraphy.
Christie’s further adds that there are less than a dozen works by Zao where green was the dominant color during his “golden age” 1960s period. Furthermore, 28.8.67 is somewhat of a watershed period where prior he was influenced by Swiss artist Paul Klee and before he began an era of more Chinese art and landscape-inspired paintings.
Lot 5 | Yayoi Kusama (b.1929) | Pumpkin (HRU), Acrylic on canvas
Painted in 2014
100 x 100 cm
Provenance:
- Victoria Miro, London
- Private collection (acquired from the above)
- Acquired from the above by the present owner
Estimate: HK$25,000,000-35,000,000 (around US$3.2-4.5 million)
Christie’s is offering a Kusama painting that brings together her three most recognizable motifs: pumpkins, polka dots, and infinity nets. These three have become the most defining parts of her artwork and stem from her own experiences growing up in Japan, as well as being someone who struggles with mental health issues. Works that combine these elements have gone on to dominate the auction scene, and her mass appeal as an artist has only continued to grow.
Pumpkins have been an object that has continued to persist as a key theme in Kusama’s work, having first seen one as a child. Kusama once stated regarding the pumpkin, “Pumpkins have been a great comfort to me since my childhood. They speak to me of the joy of living. They are humble and amusing at the same time, and I have and always will celebrate them in my art.” They first appeared in her art in 1946 during an exhibition she held in Japan and have become the main vehicle to display her other motifs.
While Kusama first saw Pumpkins as a child with her grandmother and became instantly interested in them, the polka dots predate them as something Kusama incorporated into her art, having first been seen in a sketch she made of, presumably, her mother in 1939. To her, dots were something that she saw in her hallucinations in her youth, and they managed to “obliterate” her anxieties. To Kusama, once the dots are on something, that thing proceeds to lose all meaning and sense of self.
This theme of “obliteration” extends to Kusama’s third motif, the one that surrounds the pumpkin with polka dots, the infinity nets. This web of nets and lines carries on Kusama’s idea of “self-obliteration,” as anything that is covered by the nets becomes part of a greater whole, losing its individuality. They are an extension of the polka dots, but they explore Kusama’s ideas about the universe and how these nets help us return to nothingness.
This painting was first owned by Victoria Miro, one of the UK’s most famous and influential art dealers and gallery owners. Kusama has made various works for Miro, including installations that spanned entire rooms, unique sculptures, and numerous exhibitions at Miro’s galleries.
Lot 6 | Pierre-Auguste Renoir | La Promenade au bord de la mer (Le Bois de la Chaise Noirmoutier), Oil on canvas
Painted circa 1892
66.2 x 81.4 cm
Provenance:
- Galerie Durand-Ruel, Paris, acquired directly from the artist on 9 November 1892
- Galerie Durand-Ruel, New York, transferred from the above in 1897
- Ralph M. Coe, Cleveland, acquired from the above on 20 January 1920
- Knoedler & Co., New York, acquired from the above on 30 December 1938
- Sibyl Young Clark, Ohio, acquired from the above on 21 November 1939
- Knoedler & Co., New York, acquired from the above on 4 January 1947
- Ward Eggleston Galleries, New York, acquired from the above on 13 December 1950
- Joe and Emily Lowe Foundation, New York; sale, Parke-Bernet Galleries, Inc., New York, 25 February 1970, lot 41
- Milena Jurzykowski, New York, acquired at the above sale
- The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York, bequest from the above in 1971; sale, Sotheby’s, New York, 14 May 2019, lot 53
- Acquired at the above sale by the present owner
Estimate: HK$18,000,000-28,000,000 (around US$2.3-3.6 million)
In 1892, Renoir entered what would be the twilight of his career following a diagnosis of rheumatoid arthritis that very year. This did not, however, deter his work, and that same year he produced this very lot. La Promenade au bord de la mer, or A Walk by the Sea in English, embodies Renoir’s Impressionist and romanticized view of the north French coastline.
Paintings of this location were created during an 1892 tour Renior did of northwestern France, including a summer stay in the resort town of Pornic and a lush island with crystal-clear waters called Noirmoutier, which was the inspiration for this painting.
Renoir was captivated by the place and sought to capture it using a wet-on-wet technique to create a softer background. This is contrasted by the strong sunlight portrayed in the painting, which filters through the branches and casts shadows while shining on the figures in the center of the painting. At a point, the whole thing blends together smoothly in a sort of haze that covers everything.
This softer form of painting was born from a period of introspection for Renoir that arose from various travels across the Mediterranean. There was an increased focus on idealizing nature in his work and focusing on creating harmony through carefully crafting the elements of the painting rather than utilizing spontaneity, as he did in the past.
Renoir was perhaps better known for his paintings of figures; however, these landscapes have also become renowned, especially as they have garnered more appreciation over the years. In 2007 the National Gallery of London, the National Gallery of Canada, and the Philadelphia Museum of Art held an exhibition titled Renoir Landscapes: 1865-1883. Many of the works in this exhibition were rich with life and color, many of which had inspiration that could be traced to Noirmoutier.
Lot 13 | Zhang Enli (b. 1965) | Intimacy, Oil on canvas (a set of three)
Painted in 2002
Each: 248 x 200 cm | Overall: 248 x 600 cm
Provenance:
- ShanghART Gallery, Shanghai
- Private collection, Asia
- Acquired from the above by the present owner
Estimate: HK$18,000,000-28,000,000 (around US$2.3-3.6 million)
Born in Baicheng City, Jilin province, in northeastern China, Zhang Enli graduated from the Arts & Design Institute of Wuxi Technical University in Jiangsu in 1989 and is now a teacher at the Arts and Design Institute at Donghua University in Shanghai. Throughout his work, Zhang seems to adopt unusual perspectives and viewpoints that make it seem like one is viewing a scene through a camera lens.
However, Zhang usually focuses on smaller objects that have a sort of universal feel to them, such as ashtrays, tins, or cardboard. This alternative large-scale focus on a swath of 57 figures across three different canvases is from a different period that Zhang had in the late 1990s and early 2000s, where he made these rare-to-find and large-scale works, which had segments that could be interpreted differently.
One of the theories rests on the social conditions within China at the time of this painting’s creation. The theme of the panel on the left is dancing, part of a wider Dancing series Zhang made between 1995 and 2000. At the time, ballroom dancing was all the craze in China, with various public spaces being devoted to dancing. At a time when there was much social change, poverty, and uncertainty about the future, dancing was a popular pastime that took people’s minds off of daily life.
The panel on the right’s theme is the kissing theme. Zhang’s Kissing series depicted the act less as one of tenderness and more as rash violence, where the different subjects gnaw and wrestle with one another. Zhang further represents this aggression through color by painting the faces of these subjects flush red. At the time, through commercials and media, the act of kissing became sanitized with this work displaying a more carnal interpretation of the act that Zhang may have felt was missing from art.
One of the aspects that covers the entire painting is these “leaky roof stains” that manifest as grey splotches across the work. While not a technique unique to Zhang, he uses it in two ways. The first is to trace movements. Applied in thin layers, these drips fill small spaces such as the space between strands of hair or the shape of hands, giving a sense of depth. Secondly, there is a textural component to the dripping that Zhang explored, an outgrowth of how traditional Chinese landscape ink art uses dripping.
Other Highlighted Lots:
Lot 7 | René Magritte (1898-1967) | La clairvoyance, Gouache, watercolour and coloured pencil on paper
Executed circa 1962
36 x 26.8 cm
Provenance:
- Margaret Krebs, Brussels
- Brigitte Friedlender-Salik and Veronique Dwek-Salik, Brussels, acquired from the above circa 1965; sale,
- Christie's London, 4 February 2015, lot 121
- Acquired at the above sale by the present owner
Estimate: HK$15,000,000-25,000,000 (around US$1.9-3.2 million)
Lot 16 | Zao Wou-Ki (1920-2013) | 11.2.67, Oil on canvas
Painted in 1967
73 x 60 cm
Provenance:
- Private collection, France
- Private collection, Taiwan
- Acquired from the above by the present owner
Estimate: HK$13,800,000-18,800,000 (around US$1.7-2.4 million)
Lot 5 | Yayoi Kusama (b.1929) | Pumpkin (S), Mirror-polished bronze
Executed in 2016
67.3 x 63.5 x 63.5 cm
Provenance:
- Victoria Miro, London
- Private collection (acquired from the above)
- Acquired from the above by the present owner
Estimate: HK$12,500,000-18,500,000 (around US$1.6-2.3 million)
Lot 12 | Christine Ay Tjoe (b.1973) | Layers as a Hiding Place #2, Oil on canvas
Painted in 2014
170 x 200 cm
Provenance:
- Acquired directly from the artist by the present owner
Estimate: HK$12,000,000-18,000,000 (around US$1.5-2.3 million)
Lot 12 | Liu Ye (b.1964) | Beijing Madonna, Acrylic and oil on canvas
Painted in 1994-1995
80 x 100 cm
Provenance:
- Mingjingdi Gallery, Beijing
- Private collection, Palm Springs (acquired from the above)
- Christie's New York, 17 May 2007, lot 461
- Acquired at the above sale by the present owner
Estimate: HK$12,000,000-18,000,000 (around US$1.5-2.3 million)
Auction Details:
Auction House: Christie's Hong Kong
Sale: 20th/21st Century Evening Sale
Date: 28 March 2025 | 7 pm (Hong Kong Local Time)
Number of Lots: 43